Top Real Estate Agents in Payson AZ

April 27, 2020

Who are the top real estate agents in Payson AZ?

Payson is home to quite a few real estate offices ranging from WestUSA Realty, Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty, Keller Williams, right off the Beeline HWY. Each office employs anywhere from a couple of agents to over 30+ real estate agents at some of the bigger offices like Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty. That means the Payson AZ real estate area is home to hundreds of real estate agents. Often choosing the right agent can be as daunting as picking something to watch on Netflix. So how do you know which agent is going to the best for buying or selling your home?

What you are looking for is the top real estate agents. The creme da la creme so to speak. So what separates these "top agents" from any other real estate agent out there you might wonder? Top real estate agents tend to do certain things differently. Regardless of how much experience they have, whether they call Payson home, or how many sales they have. A top real estate agent is a different breed altogether.
They communicate well and regularly with their clients. They listen. They’re proactive with the entire buying and sales process. They’re client-motivated. They know the real estate market. They know their client's time frame. They know their customer’s motivation for buying or selling a home. These agents have hustle and tenacity. I've compiled this list from years of real-life experience dealing with real estate agents day in and day out. Naturally, I couldn't exclude myself from the list of the top real estate agents in Rim Country, even if I might consider myself the best Payson realtor. 😉 I ended up basing this list off of 5 main criteria.

  1. Reputation- These agents all have a long history of delighted customers and outstanding service in the area.
  2. Experience - Masters of their craft, these agents have years of practical experience and education in the Payson real estate market. They have a combined experience of more than 50 years of real estate knowledge between them all.
  3. Availability - Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored, these agents have a proven track record for responsiveness.
  4. Professionalism - Each agent has shown to provide service with honesty, reliability, and respect.
  5. Credibility - Each agent has built customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

That being said, this list is organized in alphabetical order of each agent and not an actual ranking or order of importance.

Josh Meacham

Top Payson AZ Realtor Josh Meacham Josh grew up in the neighboring town of Heber-Overgaard but has been an active member of the Payson community nearly his entire professional career as an agent. He got his real estate license at an early age and has enjoyed mastering the craft and providing honest, reliable, customer service for all his clients. He is one of the only real estate agents to use cutting edge technology to keep an edge on the Payson home market and surrounding communities.

Kim Ross

Payson real estate agent Kim Ross Kim's life in the Rim Country started just as a visit but she quickly fell in love with the majestic mountains, the gorgeous climate, and the clear night skies of the Payson area. Since she came from the big city, the charm of Payson was like discovering a hidden treasure and she knew she had to call it home. She's got into realty in 1997, and is one of the longest active real estate agents in the area, and truly puts her clients before the bottom line. She's currently an associate broker at Keller Williams.

Marty Carpenter

Payson real estate agent Marty Carpenter Marty has called the Payson AZ 85541 zip code home for over 22 years. He's been a real estate agent here for over 14 years. His family includes 3 kids growing up in Payson’s schools including baseball, softball & basketball. He has an absolute love of the area weather with it's “mild 4 seasons”, huge Elk population that also call Payson home, Ponderosa trees, clean air, shortage of wind, close proximity to fishing, short easy drive to Phoenix & Amazing Local residents. His wife Lynn Dee is a loan officer for Amerifirst Financial and a retired grade school teacher.

Michelle Hagen

Payson real estate agent Michelle Hagan Michelle has been an agent in the area for years, she understands your needs when buying in the Payson and surrounding areas. Finding the right home is only the beginning. She will assist you every step of the way to ensure a smooth and enjoyable experience.

Suzzy Tubbs

Payson real estate agent Susan Tubbs Suzy Tubbs is an agent that understands the importance of communication, integrity, responsive communication and being a strong advocate for her clients. She has established long-lasting relationships of trust and confidence in the Payson community by not only in my business efforts but her dedication to serving the community in many facets besides her many qualities as a great agent.

Takeaway: If you or someone you know is looking to call the Payson area home you can't go wrong with any of the agents on this list. Keep in mind that being the top real estate agent doesn't always mean first place, the most sales, or "awards" from a local newspaper that you advertise in like some other agents might lead you to believe. A top real estate agent has a passion and hustle that goes beyond those things. You landed on this article because you are wondering who are the top real estate agents in Payson. I want to make it clear that this list is by no means exhaustive as there are many great realtors in the Payson area and beyond of AZ. These are ones that I would personally count as some of the best in Rim country. There is always new and emerging talent, and if you are a current agent, or know someone who would be a great addition to the list of the top Payson real estate agents, please contact me, and I'd be more than happy to get them added to the list.


(928) 268-0567
[email protected]

Pine & Strawberry
Heber Overgaard
Happy Jack
Forest Lakes
Show Low
Pinetop Lakeside
Torreon Golf Club
Chaparral Pines